Re: Who won on the fiscal cliff deal (early retirees with alot of cap gains).
Sniper,
Almost all of us lost money in 2008. In fact, only 15 AutoTracker types made money in 2008 - and, I think PoolMan must be an inside trader to have made 20%. I keep sending letters to the SEC but they don't seem to do anything - he might be Bernie Madoff:cheesy:. Anyway, Amoeba made 1.58% in the last half of 2008. That would have placed him in the top 15% of we AutoTracker people. I figure that making the top 20% is a great marker. Thus, Amoeba probably had a great year in 2008.
What I - and others in their own ways - are trying to say to Amoeba is that every year is not a crash. I didn't have a 2008 loss till I got back into equities in October 2008. Then I lost money in a very quick fashion and migrated back out. But, you have to accept losses greater than 1% or 2% to be around when the market gains 4% in a week. Like Amoeba and most others here I don't think you have to ride the pig into the pit, but you have to ride it around a little bit to see where it is going. And, with the inane IFT rules you can only jump on and off twice a month. Those mounts and dismounts are worth more than a little sway on the runnin' razorback.
The other thing I always try to get through is that the market does not respect any of our goals. Setting a goal of making 0.5% in a month and getting out to avoid risk is actually risky. January was a 4% month. You have to collect some of those gains because February may be a month long slide (it hasn't been, but this is an example). So, you get out in early January after making your half point and get in sometime in February with a goal of making that month's half point. You pick wrong and lose a whole point. Now, you are down a half point. Now you jump off the hog and onto the lily pad. Then you hear that some politicians will promise future cuts to avoid the sequester or something and jump back on - looking for the acorn. Then, after a 1% gain (now you are +0.5% again), some other aged lawyer someone voted for kyboshes the whole thing and the market dumps 3%. Now you are -2.5% and you jump to the lily pad again. Then the market realizes that they really don't care that us gubmint flaks take a 20% pay cut and booms. There you are, watching a 5% move because you have already spent your gold. 100% in, 100% out, and watching from the sidelines at a -2.5% YtoD return. Wash and repeat.
Finally, making 2% in a market that gains 14% is as bad as losing money. The S&P500 averages 9% or 10%. You probably should soften the risk a bit from a 100% C allocation, but losing 12% of gains in multiple years takes a lot of the buffer away from correction years. If you are averaging +2% per year than a single week of 2008 would wipe out years of growth and require years to recover. And, making 2% a year in your 40's will result in Social Security type distributions in your less than golden years.
So, no, folks are not really hammering the guy. He seems nice enough and spry enough and can handle his own. Just concerned. If he is 45 years old he is locking in the Alpo Meal Deal Retirement Plan. If he is 60 years old he is playing it smart.