Mike Causey's Federal Report:
Wisdom of the Crowd
April 2, 2009 - 2:00am
When it comes to developing an investment strategy are you the Lone Ranger, do you canvas the car pool, watch the market round-the-clock or let your money ride in good times or bad? In his popular book,
The Wisdom of Crowds, author James Surowiecki argues that often large groups of people are smarter, or at least have a broader range of knowledge, than a small circle of the elite. Obviously it's more complicated than that.
Like how big is the group and did you round it up at Harvard Square or your local lockup?
Earlier this week we asked real folks, people who are investing in the TSP, what they are doing during these troubled financial times. Lots of responses. Maybe you can pick up some tips, or be reassured by what you are doing, or not doing. Here are some of their systems:
"Still pinning my hopes to the folks who run the L-funds. I'm sure they are watching these markets very closely. Still hoping they will buy low on my behalf before the market bounces back up later this year (?) so I can make some of my losses back before retirement. I guess this makes me the optimist, because I know the market WILL bounce back. It's just how long it takes to do so."
Jennie
"There is one type of investor you did not ponder, perhaps because you do not think they exist. But we do! My husband actually increased our investments in the C, I and S funds last fall when the market was tumbling. I rearranged my current allotments to buy the more volatile I and S funds, and let the 80 percent I had invested in the C-fund ride. Dear hubby actually transferred everything from his F and G funds into the stock funds. We figured we definitely bought low, maybe not at the lowest, but low enough. Now we're waiting for the market to rebound. When it does, we will squirrel away some bucks into the super-safe G fund."
Laura at the IRS
"Mike, I've changed my investment strategy. I've decided I'm going to actually buy, albeit slowly, the fund with the lowest cost per share. I'm going to do this on a quarterly basis. For the First Quarter of 2009, it appears the C-Fund is the cheapest. If this trend continues, I will move my current contributions each quarter as follows: 1Q = 5%; 2Q = 20%; 3Q = 30%; 4Q = 35%; 5Q = 60%; 6Q = 70%; 7Q = 80%; 8Q = 90%; 9Q = 100%. And then, I'm going to start moving existing balances in the other funds over in $10,000 increments until all of it is in the cheapest. But if the scenario changes and another fund is at least $1 cheaper per share, then I start all over again moving my current contributions in the above schedule. I figure I can't lose. UNLESS, the cheapest fund continues to go down to the ground. Then I guess, I'll be still be here."
Eric E.
"Does flying by the seat of one's pants count? I had every thing in the G fund due to a bad case of cold feet in the middle of 2006. Feet warmed up about the middle of September last when I figured the bottom was near. Moved back in to a mix of CSI with a portion of my portfolio that I felt was "extra" (whatever that means). Needless to say, I am not quitting my day job to become a stock advisor. All this to say, every time I think I will cut my losses and duck back into G, you say something that makes sense and I decide to hang out there a little longer...thank you for keeping it real with a good dose of humor..."
Kate E.
"Yes, I have a system that worked. My wife and I are both retired CSRS. We retired at low grades. We both retired two years ago after 33 years at the grades GS-7 step 10. We both made the maximum amount of contributions to the G fund. We did not make any contributions to the L, C, S, I funds or any of the other TSP funds. We put any additional savings we had into long-term 5, 6, or 7 year FDIC insured CDs. Since our retirement we have travelled on 3 cruises: one for 2 weeks to Denmark, Norway, Sweden, and Russia. Another cruise we took was to Canada and New England. This summer we are planning a 2 week cruise from Rome to Greece. We have also taken vacations to Cape Cod. We were able to do this because neither of us trusted equities, financial planners, or Wall Street. We both live in the Arlington area. My internist and many acquaintances tell me that they cannot retire, because their TSP and their 401(k)s have lost too much money. I know their income was and is a lot higher than mine, but for some reason, I just cannot feel much sympathy for them."
Stan S.
"This is in response to your request for an investing system that 'works'. (By the way, I have at least 10 years before retirement.) From the past, I know that the stock market will go up (eventually) and that historically the returns in stocks have outpaced bonds and they stay ahead of inflation. Despite knowing the statistics, psychologically/emotionally, I kept tinkering with my TSP account every 3 to 6 months (over the past 12 to 18 months) because I just couldn't take losing so much money! I was 'hurting'. What I finally did was put my future contributions and my current balance into one of the 'L' funds (2020) and I have not looked back since! I wrote a promise to myself to not look at the balance until ~ 12/09. I also write down my investment philosophy and why I make the changes that I do so that I can try to have the emotional part of me and the rational part of me on the same page. Sometimes it is so hard to stop being schizophrenic and to maintain the discipline and patience that I think is required to achieve my goals! Moving to the lifecycle fund has seemed to calm my fears (my risk tolerance) so far."
Denise B.