But when the market drops 8-10% you'll probably just keep telling yourself that it's going lower.
No, I don't expect to have an 8-10% drop this year, or next year. When the market turns, then puts in a low and turns back up (higher high, higher low) I will buy then and have not taken the loss and bought in lower. There will be a drop in the market at some point, there has been a few already.
Why are rising defense stocks bad for the market?
Ticker Sense: Defensive Sectors Leading... So What!!!
Don't fall for broker hype. They'd much rather one goes machine gun Kelly on the buy/sell than buys and holds dividend paying stocks. Commissions mean money.
And as I have stated many times, I am not a buy and holder. You, BT, and other buy & hold investors can believe there is going to be a bull market for the next 5-10 years and that is fine. Yall have the depth of your portfolio to handle any temporary losses and the dividends to be able to continue to DCA into the market at the "price of the day." That is not me. You invest how you invest, and I trade how I trade.
Now, back to your actual question. If you only take into account big name, S&P health care stocks as defensive I see your point. There are a lot of bio tech companies represented in health care and they are not defensive. When I talk about defensive stocks, I refer to dividend paying "safe" large cap stocks. Take a look back at your link and see they define "defensive sectors (health care, consumer staples and utilities)" where utilities is way down on the list.
My same logic holds for the shift from small cap to mid cap to large cap as institutions shift their money from risky to safe investments.
When the DJIA continues to lead with the S&P-500 and NASDAQ lagging, that is a shift to large cap "safe" investments. Is that what is happening now? Don't know, as these markets are inflated and continue to make technical analysis difficult and fundamental analysis useless (majority of stocks missed and we still go up), I find it more difficult to make a decision to jump in.
Having everyone that are buy and hold investors or already in the market telling me and those on the sidelines "come on in, the market is fine" doesn't make us want to get in. Yall have different plans and objectives. Would you be saying the same thing after another Jul/Aug 2011 event... Probably, but at least those of us on the sidelines didn't just buy in at the top, then lose a significant portion of money before hoping the market comes back up to our buy in price any time soon. I have been in the market several times this year, just didn't make very good decisions as to when to be in or out, which is the risk I take deciding to not buy & hold. Yalls risk is when the market goes down, you lose; I chose to try to not be in the market when it goes down.
Not sure any of that made sense since I just woke up and will now go make breakfast for my family. I don't mean any disrespect in anything I write, just want to get the point across that we all have different styles and no matter how many times BT, JJ, or any other PermaBull buy and holder comes by, they won't change my decision... I choose not to buy high. If that means I stay on the sidelines until we get a meaningful dip, then that is my decision.