If "skin in the game" is your rationalization for a flat tax, you won't be comparing amount of skin to amount of skin. The rich guy is giving up his/her superficial squamous cells, while the poor guy has donated his organs for transplant. The idea of a progressive rate structure is to equalize the "amount of skin," so to speak, since government doesn't have a price tag to measure worth to any given purchaser. In economic terms, it is like equalizing the utility of the last dollar spent by each of them for the government services provided.
I don't remember making "skin in the game" a justification for the flat tax. If I did, sorry. My point was that so many people "take" from the system but don't put anything into it. They get used to it, they become dependent, and they are encouraged by some politicians to stay on it. It is easier to submit for federal and state assistance than to apply for a job... Where has our self-esteem gone America?
This dependancy kinda reminds me of those in Europe who are rioting because the government might stop paying them to sit on their arses... (I know it's a 'little' more complicated than that)
Y'all are talking about fairness and I can't see anything more fair than a flat tax.
As to your point about a progressive tax, how fair is that? Because I make more, I have to pay more (% wise) just because I am successful? Interesting, but bred by class envy. FWM, as usual, brings up class envy too, but he calls it a "gap between the classes." That gap was not created by those that 'have' not giving it to those that don't, but rather by a government that takes from the rich and gives it to people who: can't work, are unable to work, have too many kids to work, etc. While some people who receive the dozens of "support" programs are in legitimate need, there are a increasingly large percentage who are not.
Too many times I have heard "people in need" talk about how they make more money on Welfare/WIC/Food Stamps/etc than if they got a job. Many times I overheard these conversations in between them answering their BlackBerry while walking towards their 2011 Cadillac Escalade...
You complain about all the corruption in congress, start complaining about all the corruption in our "give away" programs; then move on to Medicare and Medicaid...
While I'm at it, let the USG spend within it's means, stop base line budgeting, quit finding more of MY money to steal and then finding socialistic ways to spend it. It is MY money, not the governments, and I know how to spend it better than the government... keep your(being generic here, don't get angry) greedy hands out of my pockets !
We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.