Intrepid Timer,
I am not necessarily disagreeing with you or concluding that you are either right or wrong.
But, what do you reference for facts to support your statements?
You can find the 10 year returns of the various TSP funds at TSP.gov.
And, why does TSP information as well as others publish information to show that the majority of people do better on buy and hold?
I believe you'll find they are talking about the last 50-100 years. The internet didn't really become popular until the mid to late 1990's. With the influx of online trading and trading programs, going much past 10-15 years is not realistic in my opinion. It's like saying "Since 1914 US automobiles have averaged 10 miles per gallon." We know in the last 20 years they have averaged higher.
Just because a person has a strategy doesn't mean it will equal success.
I agree, but if you have a plan and research it, or look at a premium services past success, with a little patience that plan should work to your advantage over time. You have to continue to research consistently and always look for ways to improve. I'm not saying it's easy or not time consuming, if it were, the pay services wouldn't be needed.
My personal opinion is leaning towards believing that if a person doesn't have some time set aside EVERY DAY to analyze information/situation, then they should buy and hold.
That's is why people pay me and why I quit my cushy government job. You have no idea how much time I spend doing this. If I could do it whenever I wanted to or just take closing prices like some premium services do, or just use moving averages if I thought they worked, like I use to, then I'd still be with the government. I put a lot on the line by quitting, if I didn't believe in my strategies, I wouldn't of done it.