Rome and today

[Asylum]

Q: ...but what did the Romans ever do for us?

A: All right, but apart from the sanitation, medicine, education, wine, public order, irrigation, roads, the fresh water system and public health, what have the Romans ever done for us?

Attendee: Brought peace?

Reg: Oh, peace - shut up!

Reg: There is not one of us who would not gladly suffer death to rid this country of the Romans once and for all.

Dissenter: Uh, well, one.

Reg: Oh, yeah, yeah, there's one. But otherwise, we're solid.

 

[The_Technician]

There are several aspects of your statement that are ...lets say interesting in today's environment....didn't produce much...overextended...they do apply today....

Have we not conquered other countries economically today?...it doesn't matter if we fired a shot or cut a throat to do it...

The interesting point of Rome is that human nature is the same.....in both societies.....yesterday as today....

Does Rome (USA) fall today for similar reasons??? is the big question....

Many reasons can be given for a fall of society....like this week...

After seeing what Obama's preacher has said over the last 20 years....it seems rather distrubing.....seeing the preacher of a church is the guiding light of his flock, is this the guidance that should be taught???.......most people try to find their way in life to provide a useful service to others, to be a contribution to society.....it seems this Christian minister is not much different than the ones teaching hatred preaching in the Middle east.....it isn't a good thing coming out of his teachings.....for anybody.

In an effort to keep the society together I would vote elsewhere.....and I don't like any of them.....they have all seemed to have forgotten why they are there......once they get in, they forget the voters.....

:worried:

 

[The_Technician]

Don't forget that they didn't produce anything. All of their income was based on conquering other societies. Eventually they ran out of places to conquer and were overextended.

There are several aspects of your statement that are ...lets say interesting in today's environment....didn't produce much...overextended...they do apply today....

Have we not conquered other countries economically today?...it doesn't matter if we fired a shot or cut a throat to do it...

The interesting point of Rome is that human nature is the same.....in both societies.....yesterday as today....

Does Rome (USA) fall today for similar reasons??? is the big question....

 

[Tempest]

Are we talking Rome- the Republic or Rome the Empire? To put a further monkey in the wrench are you all discussing the Western Roman Empire or the Eastern Roman Empire? Where was the bread basket of the Roman Empire?
And why did they have 2 emperors at the same time during one period.

Comparing 'Rome' to the US of A is about as flawed as you can get.
About as flawed as comparing Roman Empire to the British Empire.

Trivia question on the Lorica Musculata (not the true Roman name-nobody knows what the real Latin name was) seen on statue of Augustus Caeser -you have two of men that are both holding Roman Legion standards on the Lorica.
Why is that?

No fair doing a GOOGLE or Wiki
I''l be in Rome (again) on August 22 through Sept 2nd. Your blue book exams will be due when I get back.
I don't grade on a curve.

Ain't nobody collapsing anytime soon-at least not in our life time or our grandchildrens lifetimes. Beyond that it gets kinda murky.

My 2 sestertius.

P.S. I locked in my trip to Italia at the same price as 2 years ago. FWIW

 

[Idaho Dave]

Don't forget that they didn't produce anything. All of their income was based on conquering other societies. Eventually they ran out of places to conquer and were overextended.

 

[Hallatauer]

So, who is going to be the first to publish "The Decline and Fall of the American Empire"?

 

[Silverbird]

Also, lavish spending on amusing the populace, graft, debased currency, giveaways of imported food, farmers leaving overworked land, hiring of mercenaries and military elite.

 

[clester]

Economic, Military, Gradual

[(URL = <www.acs.ohio-state.edu/history/isthmia/teg/Hist111H/issues/rome1.html>) Fall of Rome]
This Ohio State site lists 3 single-issue models for the collapse:

1. Economic (lack of circulating currency and trade deficit, and other factors not clearly economic, like environmental change and decaying infrastructure)
2. Military (citizenship granted to all reduced the incentive to join the army), and
3. Gradual transformation (it never fell or fell to Islam).

Economic - Hoarding and Deficit

[(URL = <kids.osd.wednet.edu/jms/FallofRome.html>) Fall of Rome]
Causes of the fall of Rome include economic decay through hoarding of bullion, barbarian looting of the treasury, and trade deficit; military decay through attrition and disorganization; and the lack of an effective military leader.

 

[clester]

Economic Reasons for the Fall of Rome

Economic factors are cited as a major cause of the fall of Rome. These economic factors include:

• Poor management,
• Dole (bread and circuses),
• Inflation, and
• Hoarding.

 

[clester]

Here's a quote from about.com
Why did Rome Fall?

"There are adherents to single factors, but more people think Rome fell because of a combination of such factors as Christianity, decadence, lead, monetary trouble, and military problems. Even the rise of Islam is proposed as the reason for Rome's fall, by some who think the Fall of Rome happened at Constantinople in the 15th Century."

 

[clester]

I haven't studied history for many years, but I think GREED and selfishness was a factor. It is now at least. They also turned away from religion (I think they were Christians before they started to disintigrate).
Man, this does sound familiar! Where are the historians on the board?

 

[The_Technician]

Wasn't there also a economic collapse. Also familiar.

Personally, I think they got lead poisioned....it does have crazy effects on people....and they did do some weird things individually near the end of empire....

 

[clester]

Wasn't there also a economic collapse. Also familiar.

 

[The_Technician]

Started this thread based on the similarities between Rome and the US politically, economically.

Its interesting that in or about 200 AD, Rome had a transvestite 14 year old as emperor....who married his chariot driver at age 17....the senators and other political figures who were elected by the populace, spent days at the Coloseum or Hippodrome, were interested in making money for their big business contacts and forgot about the populace and their problems....essentially forgot about the problems of the state....

Sound familiar...??

:suspicious: